Talk:High-EQ personality: Difference between revisions

Jump to navigation Jump to search
no edit summary
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 13: Line 13:
:Almost all the psychiatric labels probably aren't grounded in much science beyond maybe already obvious bits about depression, anxiety, and introversion/extroversion.  Nonetheless they are fun to talk about, read about, or guess about.  Much like we're not  opposed to other armchair psychology on the wiki.  Statements about lack of scientific validity/recognition/whatever within existing articles are fine too, if this talk page is intended to lead to anything.  Lack of scientific recognition also doesn't mean not valuable, as so much of science starts off with these sort of observations.
:Almost all the psychiatric labels probably aren't grounded in much science beyond maybe already obvious bits about depression, anxiety, and introversion/extroversion.  Nonetheless they are fun to talk about, read about, or guess about.  Much like we're not  opposed to other armchair psychology on the wiki.  Statements about lack of scientific validity/recognition/whatever within existing articles are fine too, if this talk page is intended to lead to anything.  Lack of scientific recognition also doesn't mean not valuable, as so much of science starts off with these sort of observations.


Arguments about Big 5 vs. GFP just seems to be political arguments as to whether or not to frame 'bad personality' in terms of unidimensional social effectiveness or not.  The GFP seems like a pretty awful framework for those who want the psychiatric business out of politics. [[User:William|William]] ([[User talk:William|talk]]) 12:19, 20 November 2019 (UTC)
:Arguments about Big 5 vs. GFP just seems to be political arguments as to whether or not to frame 'bad personality' in terms of unidimensional social effectiveness or not.  The GFP seems like a pretty awful framework for those who want the psychiatric business out of politics. The only personality traits researchers seem to have a grasp on is extroversion/introversion and the rest just seems open to speculation[[User:William|William]] ([[User talk:William|talk]]) 12:27, 20 November 2019 (UTC)
 
[[User:William|William]] ([[User talk:William|talk]]) 12:19, 20 November 2019 (UTC)
25,837

edits

Navigation menu